Designing Signposts to Help Users Discover and Engage with the Community

My Role

Product Designer

My Team

Irina, Peter,

Madi, Meenhaz

Timeline

May 2024 - Aug 2024

My Role

Product Designer

My Team

Irina, Peter, Madi, Meenhaz

Timeline

May 2024 - Aug 2024

Designing Signposts to Help Users Discover and Engage with the Community

Introduction

At Community & Utility, we’ve been exploring ways to highlight community features across our brands and platforms. The idea behind Community Signpost is simple: help users notice these elements more easily and encourage them to engage, whether they’re regular contributors or just browsing.

My Role

As the product designer on this project, I co-led the end-to-end design process - from early ideation to final specs and developer handoff. I collaborated closely with other designers to shape the overall concept, and together we ran multiple workshops focused on design thinking, placement strategies across app and web, and UX writing.

I spent 1 week creating detailed design specs, followed by the handoff to developers. Post-handoff, I dedicated 2 weeks to design QA, working closely with the development team to ensure everything shipped matched the intended experience.

Signposting

User awareness

Behaviour nudges

User awareness

Community engagement

Web & app implementation

Behaviour nudges

Community engagement

Web & app implementation

Web & app implementation

Community engagement

Current design challenge

The absence of a comment count on the icon led to user frustration when redirected to empty threads. Hyperlinks on WIRED required clearer distinction, while Epi’s text needed simplification to avoid redundancy. Additionally, WIRED and AD Pro featured action bars without displaying review metrics, limiting context for users.

Design Workshop

Conducted multiple design and stakeholder workshops to determine optimal content placement, define the type of content to include, refine copy for dedicated sections, and assess feasibility from an engineering perspective.

Competitive Research

Analyzed leading forums and review platforms such as Airbnb, Skyscanner, MakeMyTrip, Amazon, and others to understand best practices for showcasing reviews in a way that is easy to spot and navigate.

User Interviews

Conducted multiple rounds of user interviews before and after design iterations to evaluate satisfaction levels, uncover usability gaps, and ensure the final solution addressed user needs effectively.

Our Approach

Based on the data insights, we identified the key problem statements and set out to design a solution that addressed the needs of our end users. To achieve this, we followed three core UX approaches:

Problem Statement

#1

Community links on recipe/article pages are easy to overlook due to poor visibility and redundant placement.

#2

Community links placed at the top of pages fail to drive users to explore, as many never scroll to that section.

#3

The community forum is often missed on the homepage, resulting in low user engagement.

Our Approach

Based on the data insights, we identified the key problem statements and set out to design a solution that addressed the needs of our end users. To achieve this, we followed three core UX approaches:

Design Workshop

Conducted multiple design and stakeholder workshops to determine optimal content placement, define the type of content to include, refine copy for dedicated sections, and assess feasibility from an engineering perspective.

Competitive Research

Analyzed leading forums and review platforms such as Airbnb, Skyscanner, MakeMyTrip, Amazon, and others to understand best practices for showcasing reviews in a way that is easy to spot and navigate.

User Interviews

Conducted multiple rounds of user interviews before and after design iterations to evaluate satisfaction levels, uncover usability gaps, and ensure the final solution addressed user needs effectively.

Design Workshop

Goal: To create strong starting points for design exploration, using existing examples, past projects, or new feature ideas. The aim is to find opportunities and see where we can make the most impact. We divided the workshop content into three segments to understand both the designer’s and the user’s perspectives.

Augmenting Conde Content with Peer Perspectives

Augmenting Conde Content with Peer Perspectives

Augmenting Conde Content with Peer Perspectives

As a user, I want to meet like-minded people

As a user, I want to meet like-minded people

As a user, I want to meet like-minded people

As a user, I want interactive ways to engage with the brand

As a user, I want interactive ways to engage with the brand

As a user, I want interactive ways to engage with the brand

Competitive Research

Preview Reviews and Ratings in a New Window, on the Same Page (Scroll Down) and Mid-Page Signposting

Ratings or review metrics were presented as clickable/tappable links

Many featured a prominently highlighted review section at the top of the page, paired with metrics to encourage users to explore the article further.

For seamless navigation, brands employed varied approaches such as review modals, direct scroll-to-review functionality, or opening reviews in a dedicated window.

User Interview

Goal

To gather first impressions as users navigate the concepts, capturing their reactions, understanding, expectations, and pain points, and using these insights to iteratively improve the signposting designs.

Methodology

A 30-minute unmoderated study on UserTesting.com with 5 participants per brand (WIRED and Epicurious) and per concept, totalling 20 participants.

Respondent Qualifications

  • All respondents meet the following criteria:

  • US adults aged 18-60

  • Household income of $20k+

  • A mix of paid and free users of the brand

  • Participates in related online communities

Study Dates

July – August, 2024

Goal

To gather first impressions as users navigate the concepts, capturing their reactions, understanding, expectations, and pain points, and using these insights to iteratively improve the signposting designs.

Methodology

A 30-minute unmoderated study on UserTesting.com with 5 participants per brand (WIRED and Epicurious) and per concept, totalling 20 participants.

Respondent Qualifications

  • All respondents meet the following criteria:

  • US adults aged 18-60

  • Household income of $20k+

  • A mix of paid and free users of the brand

  • Participates in related online communities

Study Dates

July – August, 2024

What we tested on the top of article page

What we tested on the top of article page

What we tested in the mid-section of the article page

What we tested in the mid-section of the article page

What We Shipped

#1 Community Quick Links on Recipe/Article Pages

#2 Mid-Content Signposting to Drive User Engagement

#1 Community Quick Links on Recipe/Article Pages

#2 Mid-Content Signposting to Drive User Engagement

#3 Spotlighting Community on Homepage

#3 Spotlighting Community on Homepage

User Interview

Goal

To gather first impressions as users navigate the concepts, capturing their reactions, understanding, expectations, and pain points, and using these insights to iteratively improve the signposting designs.

Methodology

A 30-minute unmoderated study on UserTesting.com with 5 participants per brand (WIRED and Epicurious) and per concept, totalling 20 participants.

Respondent Qualifications

  • All respondents meet the following criteria:

  • US adults aged 18-60

  • Household income of $20k+

  • A mix of paid and free users of the brand

  • Participates in related online communities

Study Dates

July – August, 2024

What We Shipped

Create a free website with Framer, the website builder loved by startups, designers and agencies.